You are currently viewing 205. K&P’s Gratis Pipe Tool: A Dating Guide (Revised)

205. K&P’s Gratis Pipe Tool: A Dating Guide (Revised)

(Rev. 07/15/2022 with thanks to Dixon Smith)

Back in 2018 Kris Parry at the Black Swan Shoppe sent me a Peterson-branded 3-in-1 pipe tool.* It turned out to be a generic but well-made instrument but got me thinking about the original Gratis Pipe Tools that accompanied System pipes from 1891 until 1963 or so. With a gift from my co-author Gary Malmberg and research on K&P’s 1896 catalog, I can now offer a visual history and tentative dating guide.

Bach Smokes the Thinking Man’s Pipe (a 4s, of course)

As long as there have been pipes, there have been tampers. If you haven’t used your finger as a tamp, you probably haven’t smoked more than a bowl or two, because along about the second or third burned finger, you learned to keep a tamper handy. In the beginning tampers were called “stoppers” and Johann Sebastian Bach—a man who loved his pipe—had this to say about them:

 How oft it happens when one’s smoking:
The stopper’s missing from its shelf,
And as one goes with one’s finger poking
Into the bowl and burns oneself.
If in the pipe such pain doeth dwell,
How hot must be the pains of Hell! *

By about 1850, or twenty years before briar began to come onto the pipe smoking scene in a big way, pipemen had come to a consensus that there are three operations which require some kind of tool when smoking one’s pipe: (1) “stopping” or “tamping,” (2) clearing clogs from the draft hole, and (3) unloading smoked and unsmoked tobacco from the chamber.

Charles Peterson was not only a great artisan, inventor and entrepreneur but a guy who smoked like a freight train, so he knew from the get-go that his Patent System pipes deserved a quick-reach all-purpose tool to keep them functioning their best. Having already provided a fairly comprehensive user’s guide in the 1896 catalog, he realized that charity consists more in action than words. Accordingly, from the outset his company provided every single System pipe they made with a 3-in-1 pipe tool. For the next seventy years, it was the best advertising K&P could have done: every time a pipeman picked up the Gratis tool, he remembered how much he liked his System pipe.

Czech, mate? A close copy of the K&P Gratis Tool

The Gratis Tool is still seen in auctions a few times a year on eBay, but most smokers know it through its later clone, the “Czech Tool” (so-called because the genuine article says MADE IN over CZECH REPUBLIC on the tamper stem).

It would be great to say that Charles Peterson invented the 3-in-1 tool, or at least patented K&P’s version, but as it turns out earlier versions had already been circulation for a while.

One of the first patents for a 3-in-1 was by Gustavus Miller, from 1864. In his patent letter he writes that “it is well known that devices of similar kind have been used long since by smokers; but they were not so complete as mine, and they lacked the spring, which constitutes the essential part of my improvements.”

Among US patents, there is one filed in 1905 by George Walker of Newton, Massachusetts. Like Miller before him, he states that the three parts of the tool “are well known to pipe-smokers,” his patent covering a fourth tool, a flexible cleaning rod concealed in the bore of the tamp (#6).

One of the great gurus of our hobby is Fred Hanna, a Doctor of Pipes. If you haven’t read his deliciously satirical essay on “The Hidden Benefits of the Expensive Pipe Tamper,” I suggest you immediately do so, which can be found  in his classic (yet sadly out-of-print) book The Perfect Smoke (2012).

Hanna is seemingly able to get along with just a tamper, having no need of either pick or spoon. There will be those who suspect he wasn’t brought up with tools or say he doesn’t go in for the manly D-I-Y aspects of the hobby, but they’re wrong. It’s because as a Doctor of Pipes he is a veritable Jedi Knight in the pipe-smoking world and never has clogged air holes, never has packed his pipes too tightly and never, ever finds his perfect straight-grain artisan pipe chambers choked with ash making it impossible to burn the unsmoked tobacco beneath.

One step up from the single-function tamper is the dual-function, made rather like a sword stick and consisting of a tamper with a screw-out poker (aka a reamer) concealed in its shank. You may think Hanna occasionally sneaks out the poker of his genuine unicorn tusk tamp to unclog the draft hole. Fie! Not he. It is there only to give succor to those in need around him.

Anyone who has encountered the frustration of a clogged draft-hole knows the value of a poker, but only System and army-mount users can safely remove the mouthpiece during smoking to unclog the draft. While System users may never encounter a clog in the mouthpiece (which is designed to prevent large matter from ever ascending into its draft), they will sometimes find a clog in the draft hole to the chamber.

I couldn’t live without a poker, having passed my smoking life as one of those poor sods who sometimes packs his tobacco too tightly and must scoop it all out and begin again. I am also sometimes cursed by a clogged air hole and unable to draw, which typically happens in an otherwise idyllic smoke.

At the Chicago show in 2018, my co-author Gary Malmberg taught me a neat use of the poker. I like to smoke out my bowl to the bottom—a dubious practice frowned on by many among the Smoking Elite. When I get about three-quarters of the way through the bowl it often happens that I tamp the surface but can’t get a good relight. When Gary saw me doing this, being the wise man he is, said, “That’s one of the reasons you’ve got a pick in the 3-in-1 tool: take the pick and gently poke three or four air holes down through the layer of ash and tobacco beneath to the bottom of the bowl, being careful not to push the pick into the chamber floor.” Well, I tried it, and presto, as they say. Problem solved. Merrily I smoke along to the end of the ride.

In addition to the tamper and poker, a spoon or shovel is also essential. While Pipe-Smoking Superheroes simply turn their pipes over and watch ash drift effortlessly down and across the universe, I often find my pipes need some coaxing, cajoling and occasional cussing. Especially if I didn’t have time to smoke out the bowl. I usually begin with the poker to loosen the dottle and then if a slap on the palm doesn’t drop it out, use the shovel, never forgetting to say (as it rolls out) “Alas poor Yorick! I knew him, Horatio.”



So now we come to the four different pipe tools offered by Kapp & Peterson with their System pipes. As far as I can tell at this point, there were three of them, one made in Germany and two in the UK.


1. The Compliment Tool.

The first version of the Gratis Tool might be called the “Compliment Tool,” since it is stamped COMPLIMENT WITH PETERSON’S PATENT PIPE. It is seen only in an illustration on page 21 of the 1896 catalog. While not seen in the engraving, this tool bears the words MADE IN GERMANY around the hinge and COMPLIMENT with on the spoon shank:

1896 Catalog Compliment Tool

The word on the shank is interesting—why it didn’t read complimentary with or compliments with? I wonder if there was a translation error somewhere along the line. That it was made in Germany is no surprise, as Charles Peterson not only was a fluent German speaker (it was one of three languages spoken in Latvia where he was born) but had many business associates in German-speaking countries.

Some fascinating for Pete Geeks can be seen on the inside of the spoon: the engraving of a cutaway demonstrator Patent System.


2. The 1906 Catalog Gratis Tool.

The second three-in-one tool is seen in the 1906 catalog, so we’ll call it the “1906 Catalog Gratis Tool.” This is a photogravure image (i.e., produced from a photographic negative transferred to a metal plate and etched in) which gives it its wonderful yesteryear flavor. It is obviously the same design as the 1896, but COMPLIMENTS on the spoon shank has been replaced by GRATIS the words MADE IN GERMANY removed from the hinge—or at least in the illustration, as I have no physical specimen to document.

1906 Catalog Gratis Tool

Where it was made or if it was only a prototype and never really entered production I couldn’t say. Did it also have the engraving of a demonstrator System on the inside of the spoon? If anyone has one of these, perhaps they can share images of it with us at some point.


3. The Gratis Patent Tool (c. 1907-18).

The third version of the pipe tool, which we’ll call the “Gratis Patent Tool” (c. 1907-18) seems to have appeared somewhere after the 1906 catalog and obviously before the end of the Patent era. In The Peterson Pipe: The Story of Kapp & Peterson, we date the Patent era from 1891 to 1921, as the Irish Free State was formed in 1922. We did this for convenience’s sake, as the patent for the System pipe actually expired in 1912, the final patent on the Peterson lip expired in 1918 and the IFS stamp could have been in use as early as 1922 when the Irish Free State was formed.

Gratis Patent Tool

Why K&P transferred manufacture of the pipe tool from Germany to Britain is anyone’s guess, although cost is usually a motivating factor in any business decision. What is certain is that at some point–and I conjecture it was during the System’s patent life, that is, after the 1906 catalog photo but long before the expiration of the final patent in 1918–a new tool was commissioned and made.

How long K&P used this tool Gratis Patent tool is again anyone’s guess. As they were a business they would doubtless not have thrown away unused product, but at some point they knew they would need a new, correctly labeled one. I had earlier wondered how the beginning of hostilities resulting in the Great War in 1914 may have impacted the transfer of manufacture of the tool, but there’s really no way of knowing when German production would have been impossible to import to Ireland so I lay that aside as an insoluble problem for now.

What is important is to note that this third version of the Gratis tool has the word PATENT in the middle of the spoon, because its successor will not.


4. The Final Gratis Tool.

The fourth and final version of the Gratis Tool is identical to the third tool aside from the omission of the word PATENT from the middle of the spoon. I’ve seen this fourth version a few times a year since I began daily study of eBay’s Peterson listings back around 2009, although both it and the Gratis Patent tool can be usually be seen at least on an annual basis.

The Final Gratis Tool

We know the Gratis Tool was included in System boxes in its own cellophane paper jacket at least through the 1950s but perhaps as late as 1963, when the factory discontinued bone tenons (substituting them with aluminum) and began using pressed nickel ferrules exclusively for Standard Systems (before that, some were soldered by hand).

While I like the heft of the recent generic Peterson pipe tool and love the Lagnole pipe knife, neither has a spoon, opting for a reamer instead. The Lagnole’s reamer can be used as a spoon but without near the success.

As is so often the case, Charles Peterson and the Patent-era Kapp & Peterson had it right: nickel-plated poker, tamper, spoon on a hinge with a brass grommet. It is also the correct weight for a tamper, at least in the sage opinion of one of the great gurus of pipe smoking, Shane Ireland, who recently told me that heavy tampers can be a hazard because they tempt the smoker to use far too much torque in tamping, when in fact a tamper should be used as gently as possible to flatten and depress the ash crown.   Finally, it was free with every Peterson System. Invincible to anything but rust and nearly impervious to that. Chales Peterson knew how to make the smoker happy.

It would be grand (as my Irish friends say) if K&P would bring back the Gratis Tool with every System pipe or even as a separate-purchase accessory in nickel plate or sterling. But along with the original nickel-mount marks, I think the only place we’re going to find it is in the estate listings on eBay.


Thanks for Dixon Smith for pointing out there were actually FOUR tools
and prompting me to revise this post!
Thanks to Gary Malmberg for the “Compliments” pipe tool.
Finally, hanks to J. S. Bach for the soundtrack.


Rath Dé ort!


*So check out Kris’s fantastic selection of Petes, especially the rare ones, as he’s got plenty!






5 3 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Steven Hersey
Steven Hersey
3 years ago

A super article, and well written with a lively style. The tool, in whatever form it takes, has been an essential extra arm (or finger) together with the obligatory pipe cleaners, paper tissues (I buy boxes of tissues for the express purposes of both dumping dottle scraped out by the tool, and cleaning the reservoir) and tobacco pouch as part of my pipe smoker’s kit. Small, handy and irreplaceable. I love these old spoon tampers and have yet to own, let alone, see one. A bit of history, nostalgia and craftsmanship, and a pleasure to see them. Great advice re… Read more »

Jorgen Jensen
Jorgen Jensen
3 years ago

Good morning, smoking a 20S. Fine, more smoking culture.
And yes, about 2016 they sent a free tool with every Peterson brought from England.
At a time I had eight so I took six to a clubmeeting and said
” someone wants a free tool” and they were gone within 10 seconds. So I went home to try one and now use it daily..

3 years ago

Great article and very interesting!

Bryan Gesinger
Bryan Gesinger
3 years ago

What a great post regarding a fixture in the history of Kapp and Peterson. “That [the tamper included with a new Peterson] was made in Germany is no surprise, as Charles Peterson not only was a fluent German speaker (it was one of three languages spoken in Latvia where he was born) but had many business associates in German-speaking countries.” Moreover: the Kapp Bros. hailed from Nuremberg. Would that not have been an influential consideration in the supply chain? In any case, I should very much like to possess an authentic specimen for use in my prized Petes (as I… Read more »

John Schantz
John Schantz
3 years ago

I’ve been looking for a Peterson gratis pipe tool on EBay for a few years now. I have seen a few, but I am to cheap to bid as high as the auctions go. It seems strange that they are so few and far between if they were provided with every system pipe sold over the course of 50+ years. I have seen plenty of old System Pete’s for sale, but only a handful of the pipe tools. I’m still looking?

3 years ago

My British made Patent stopper, given by a very dear friend, is very special to me. The sentimental feelings exist, without his knowledge, as in my father’s (who passed when I was thirteen) pipe smoking things was a Gratis, but it was lost in my college days. Of course, I had no idea at the time that there was a Peterson Pipe, and never thought more about such an unassuming thing. But, after beginning to enjoy pipes, including Peterson’s, the memory of that tamper surfaced! I gave up trying to find another years ago. My friend not only brought that… Read more »

Robert P
Robert P
1 year ago

I have one that doesn’t match any of the pictures you have. Maybe it is the 1906 you haven’t actually seen an example of?

11 months ago

I have my grandfathers Peterson tool. It has imprinting on the “spoon” only. Says Gratis with Peterson’s patent pipe. Have you ever seen this model?

11 months ago
Reply to  Mark Irwin

I’ll look for your email.

11 months ago
Reply to  Mark Irwin

I haven’t seen one like it on the post.